Post by sundark100 on Apr 6, 2012 2:50:47 GMT -5
6/4/12
This is wrt the TALams mentioned for various songs in karnatik.com.
Specially, when it comes to deshAdi and madhyAdi TALams, there seems to be some incorrectness as can be seen from the discussions in rasikas.org – see the link below.
I request you to pl refer to Post # 9 of :
www.rasikas.org/forum/viewtopic.php?f=8&t=17525
where “rshankar” has advised me to contact yr website for any feedback on the links provided in karnatik.com.
(Then) , pl also see Post # 7 by “mohan” :
“The definitions on karnatik.com are incorrect with respect to deshadi and madhyadi. vasantakokilam's definitions above are more appropriate.”
You may then read the whole thread, and ONLY AFTER further consulting with experts, make the necessary corrections in the respective links (and other related links too ! – like in those other songs’ links, where these TALams appear).
This is because most of us often take the Lyrics’ / Ragams’ / Composers’ webpages of karnatik.com almost as Bible Refs.
It seems that atleast 4 songs mentioned in the above rasikas.org site (pl refer Posts 4 and 5 for individual links of these 4 Songs), and the info given in yr site’s link : www.karnatik.com/ctaala.shtml may need corrections ??
PS : Would appreciate if you could ack NOW, and also let us know WHEN you have made the corrections ie, to me and a Post in the above rasikas Thread, so that all of us know that the necessary corrections have been done for ALL the deshAdi, madhyAdi and Plain Adi Songs – as necessary.
Rgds
...
This is wrt the TALams mentioned for various songs in karnatik.com.
Specially, when it comes to deshAdi and madhyAdi TALams, there seems to be some incorrectness as can be seen from the discussions in rasikas.org – see the link below.
I request you to pl refer to Post # 9 of :
www.rasikas.org/forum/viewtopic.php?f=8&t=17525
where “rshankar” has advised me to contact yr website for any feedback on the links provided in karnatik.com.
(Then) , pl also see Post # 7 by “mohan” :
“The definitions on karnatik.com are incorrect with respect to deshadi and madhyadi. vasantakokilam's definitions above are more appropriate.”
You may then read the whole thread, and ONLY AFTER further consulting with experts, make the necessary corrections in the respective links (and other related links too ! – like in those other songs’ links, where these TALams appear).
This is because most of us often take the Lyrics’ / Ragams’ / Composers’ webpages of karnatik.com almost as Bible Refs.
It seems that atleast 4 songs mentioned in the above rasikas.org site (pl refer Posts 4 and 5 for individual links of these 4 Songs), and the info given in yr site’s link : www.karnatik.com/ctaala.shtml may need corrections ??
PS : Would appreciate if you could ack NOW, and also let us know WHEN you have made the corrections ie, to me and a Post in the above rasikas Thread, so that all of us know that the necessary corrections have been done for ALL the deshAdi, madhyAdi and Plain Adi Songs – as necessary.
Rgds
...
